Apple iPod Shuffle (1GB, 2nd Generation, Orange) - Expert Reviews

Review summary: The more I think about it, it's probably about time that Apple shifted its iPod lineup and eliminated the smallest member altogether...

Verdict: With the pending launch of the $199 Apple iPhone 3G just around the corner, many people are pondering why they would even bother with the more expensive (though sans contract) iPod touch. After all, why would you spend an extra $200 on what is effectively

Review summary: The new colour scheme is similar to that of the new nanos

Pros: Small and cuteBuilt-in clipVery good audio

Cons: Very poor valueStill only 1GBNo new features

Verdict: The iPod shuffle is a decent enough device but it's poor value. We'd have been happier if it had been refreshed to 2GB with the other iPod lines, but, as it stands, it gets a lukewarm review this time around

Review summary: The new third-generation iPod shuffle is pretty much the same as the second-generation design -- same 1GB memory, cute dock and integrated clip -- but now it's available in metallic blue, purple, green, red and silver and it costs less, at just £49

Pros: Even cheaper than the second-gen shuffle; dead-simple user interface with satisfying tactile controls; integrated belt clip provides a handy way to keep track of the player; available in five metallic colours; package includes a cute little syncing cradle

Cons: No screen, so there's no way to navigate easily among artists, albums or playlists; only offers so-so sound quality; might be too small for some users; non-standard USB syncing takes away from its plug-and-go appeal

Verdict: If you like your music playback simple and your device nearly invisible, the third-generation iPod shuffle will suit you well. But absentminded users should steer clear of this easy-to-misplace player

Review summary: If you have a penchant for minimalist, well-engineered design then the second generation Shuffle should be on your short-list.

Verdict: I probably wouldn't like to have a Shuffle as my main music player, simply because it doesn't have a screen and I like to have a modicum of control over the order in which my music plays. However, there are many things to like about the new Shuffle and it